Re: Coulter ELITE vs BD FACScalibur

Peter J Openshaw [Medicine] (p.openshaw@ic.ac.uk)
Thu, 30 Nov 1995 09:07:39 GMT

We have a new-ish Elite ESP and have not found that it breaks down too
often. It is a state of the art instrument, and works well if looked after
properly. It would seem much better than a FACScalibur if you want serious
sorting at reasonable speed- see previous messages on the cytometry board.

At 18:15 28/11/95 +0000, Phillip E. Klebba wrote:
>Greetings fellow flow afficionados,
>
>I need help. I have the need and the $$$$$$ to purchase a sorting
>instrument. The machines under consideration are a BD FACScalibur and a
>Coulter Elite ESP. However, the new sorting mechanism of the BD instrument
>makes it difficult to compare it with the Coulter.
>
>Our sorting needs are as follows. We are working with bacteria, and sorting
>cells recognized by MAbs against surface epitopes. In some cases the
>particles of interest may be rare events (10-5). The sorted cells must be
>recovered and re-cultured. I have heard from the BD salesman that the
>Coulter instrument is unreliable for sorting and continually down for
>service, and from the Coulter salesman I have heard remarks about the slow
>sorting speed of the FACScalibur, and low viability of cells recovered with
>the cell concentrator.
>
>Can anyone provide comments and experience that might resolve some of these
>considerations. Although price is a question, the efficacy of the
>instruments is primary. Thanks in advance for any help that you might provide.
>
>PEK
>
>Phillip E. Klebba, Ph. D.
>Associate Professor of Chemistry and Biochemistry
>University of Oklahoma
>Norman, OK 73019
>
>Tel: 405-325-4969
>Fax: 405-325-6111
>Internet: pklebba@aardvark.ucs.uoknor.edu
>
>
>
Peter Openshaw (p.openshaw@ic.ac.uk)
Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellow in Clinical Sciences,
Respiratory Medicine, Imperial College,
St Mary's Hospital Medical School
London W2 1PG UK. EMail: Direct line: +44 171 594 3853/4
Swithcboard: (0171) 723 1252 ext 3854 Fax: 724 7349


Home Page Table of Contents Sponsors Web Sites
CD ROM Vol 2 was produced by staff at the Purdue University Cytometry Laboratories and distributed free of charge as an educational service to the cytometry community. If you have any comments please direct them to Dr. J. Paul Robinson, Professor & Director, PUCL, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907. Phone:(317) 494-0757; FAX (317) 494-0517; Web http://www.cyto.purdue.edu EMAIL robinson@flowcyt.cyto.purdue.edu